Join Telegram Group Join Now
Join Facebook Group Join Now

When Lack Of Data Gets In The Way Of Affirmative Action

March 2022 noticed two essential courtroom judgements on reservation insurance policies in two totally different Indian states, with one frequent hyperlink. In Maharashtra, the state authorities had carved out a separate 27% Different Backward Lessons (OBC) quota in native physique elections. This was struck down by the Supreme Court docket, because it didn’t meet the necessary triple take a look at laid down by the courtroom. Particularly, the courtroom cited an absence of rigorous empirical examine and analysis for the state’s determination on this OBC quota.

In Tamil Nadu, the state meeting had handed a invoice offering inside reservations of 10.5% for the Vanniyar neighborhood (of Vanniakula Kshatriyas) in jobs and schooling ( The Supreme Court docket struck this down as effectively, saying that there is no such thing as a substantial foundation for this legislative motion aimed toward offering a quota particularly for a single OBC neighborhood. This similar case was first determined by the Madras excessive courtroom, which had acknowledged that “the enactment was handed by the state with none quantifiable knowledge” and with none goal criterion ( That is the core downside that was recognized by each these judgements: an absence of evidence-driven policymaking for reservations.

A typical downside of vast divergences: Whereas reservations are relevant all throughout India, it’s no secret that there are vast state-level variations throughout many parameters. For instance, about 55% of Maharashtra’s inhabitants is eligible for reservations, as many of the state’s persons are categorised as Scheduled Caste, Scheduled Tribe or OBC, whereas in Tamil Nadu, a a lot greater 97.2% of the state inhabitants is classed likewise.

Now, OBCs represent about 33.8% of Maharashtra’s inhabitants, whereas in Tamil Nadu, a whopping 76% of the inhabitants is classed as OBC, although this huge group of individuals is additional divided ( into Most Backward Lessons (MBCs), Backward Lessons (BCs), Backward Class Muslims (BCMs) and Denotified Communities (DNCs). Additional, in Maharashtra, the whole variety of seats reserved for OBC/SC/ST candidates is capped at 50%, as per a directive of India’s high courtroom within the Indra Sawhney case. Nonetheless, in Tamil Nadu, a a lot greater 69% of seats fall underneath the reserved class, which is clearly an exception to that Supreme Court docket ruling. In reality, half the seats in Tamil Nadu are reserved solely for OBC candidates.

Regardless of these assorted approaches in direction of reservations and the nation’s large multi-decade funding in affirmative motion, an absence of dependable caste-level knowledge stays a relentless issue that hampers enhancements of the programme.

We should gather the precise knowledge: Reservations have been designed for influence on the caste degree. Their influence is less complicated to evaluate at a gaggle degree, whether or not it’s OBCs, SCs or STs. Nonetheless, whether or not particular person castes inside these teams have benefitted or not stays unclear.

As per the Rohini Fee report, over 1,000 OBC caste teams haven’t obtained any profit in anyway from India’s reservation programme (, signifying an enormous imbalance within the distribution of its advantages.

The nation’s lack of focused knowledge assortment round reservations stays a significant miss, which makes house for an imbalance between caste teams in entry to alternatives. Thus, there’s a dire want to gather the precise knowledge on the caste degree to make the reservation system simpler. Doing so wouldn’t solely assist us perceive the inhabitants of every group, but in addition their socioeconomic and political backwardness and the advantages which have accrued from reservations to this point.

What knowledge to gather? The federal government already captures the OBC/SC/ST standing of people on the college degree. Nonetheless, this must filter additional all the way down to the extent of caste identification (

This is able to enable us to simply estimate the inhabitants ranges of every caste group. Additional, this could additionally enable us to evaluate the proportion of scholars attending authorities faculties from every caste group, which in flip would supply us a peek into relative ranges of deprivation between totally different castes.

The proliferation of affirmative motion: Lots of of presidency schemes in the present day are administered for OBCs, SCs, and STs throughout the nation, by way of each the Central and state governments. Capturing the precise caste knowledge of those beneficiaries, particularly of welfare schemes like these in place for meals distribution and jobs underneath the Mahatma Gandhi Nationwide Rural Employment Assure Act, would assist us perceive the proportion of every group that’s compelled to avail of those advantages.

Many state governments are working a digitization programme for caste certificates ( . By linking this knowledge with Aadhaar, a database will be created to trace reservation advantages throughout all castes.

The 2 latest Supreme Court docket judgements have proven the dire have to construct proof for furthering the reason for social justice. Capturing acceptable knowledge holds the important thing to constructing this proof, which ought to embody measurements of the influence of reservations on the caste and neighborhood degree, and never merely at a gaggle degree.

State and central governments have been fast to implement digitization in lots of fields. These administrations ought to present the identical vigour within the reservation programme by creating a sturdy data-backed proof structure for assessing and implementing affirmative motion.

Omkar Sathe & Sahil Deo are, respectively, affiliate companion and co-founder of CPC Analytics

Subscribe to Mint Newsletters

* Enter a legitimate electronic mail

* Thanks for subscribing to our publication.

Join Telegram Group Join Now
Join Facebook Group Join Now

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.